
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Mizoram
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Section |
1972-74 1974-79 (2 years) |
1979-80 1980-85 (1 year) |
1984-85 (1 year) |
||
|
Agriculture |
20 |
106.4 |
40.8 |
305.2 |
104 |
|
Industry |
3.1 |
10.8 |
5.3 |
40.5 |
20 |
|
Energy |
10.1 |
40.4 |
20.1 |
108 |
60 |
|
Communication |
30.4 |
102.8 |
40.6 |
302.5 |
100 |
|
Education |
20.2 |
100.4 |
50.2 |
306.3 |
80 |
|
Total |
90.3 |
40.6 |
107.7 |
1300 |
400 |
Per
Capita Plan Expenditure in Select States
(in
millions of rupees) [13]
|
State |
4th Plan (1969-74) |
5th Plan (1974-79) |
6th Plan (1980-85) |
|
Arunachal |
449 |
1199 |
3333 |
|
Mizoram |
282 |
1249 |
2795 |
|
Nagaland |
741 |
1565 |
2723 |
|
All India |
145 |
333 |
706 |
As against the 6th Plan outlay
of 1300 million rupees for Mizoram, the 7th Plan (1985-90) outlay
was 2600 million rupees, which further and dramatically raised the
percentage as compared to the All India average.
The
Centre had thus gone all-out to reduce the economic imbalances between
the more developed parts of the country, and the hill tribal areas
of the Northeast. This decidedly took the wind out of the secessionists
main grievance and propaganda. But internally, within these States, all was
not well with the way this windfall of money was utilised. With a burgeoning bureaucracy, public employment
in 1985 stood at 20,000 in Mizoram, with a population of less than
half a million people. With
easy money got in the form of relief, subsidies and loans,
Mizoram suddenly became one of the best markets for electronic and
other consumer goods in the country.
[14]
This was, however, expected to
be nothing more than a temporary bonanza, which created conditions
for peace but kept the economy stagnant. As Lalmachhuana appropriately
points out:
Quite
a large proportion of the money incomes thus generated...has been
grasped by a few rich (inclusive of big contractors) and spent on
luxuries. This has had something of a demonstration
effect and now many people are in a great hurry to get easy
money and are less willing to do manual work.
This has brought about a change in social values, which tends
to create and perpetuate economic and social injustice in society.
It is no wonder that in spite of huge expenditure incurred in monetary
terms after the formation of the Union Territory in 1972, the economy
remains more or less stagnant.
[15]
The politician-bureaucrat-contractor
nexus, which converted the highest per capita public expenditure in
the country into an item of consumption, may have long-term economic
repercussions. In the short-term, however, it created, among a very
large number of people, an aversion for the hard life of the insurgency
period and a strong motivation for the continuance of the paid
holiday. It made integration with India an overwhelming
vested interest for the most vocal and influential segment of society.
An IAS officer could build a house with a large government loan at
low rate of interest, and then rent it out to a government department
at the rate fixed by a colleague. [16]
A fifty per cent advance could be given to a
supplier just having a semblance of access to the articles intended
to be supplied [17]
or to a contractor for constructing a building
that would take five years to build.
Fake subsidies in thousands of rupees for minor irrigation,
contour terracing and plantations were distributed rampantly.
However, measures such as the reimbursement of three-fourths of the
expenditure and the cost of air travel for anybody going 2000 miles
to the Christian Medical College Hospital in Vellore in south India
for treatment, brought about tremendous social good, individual happiness,
and goodwill for India.
[18]
Indira Gandhi's Electoral Intervention
There
was another development in Mizoram with more far-reaching consequences.
Although an insignificant Congress following had existed in Mizoram
from 1947 onwards, the national parties had, by and large, remained
outside the pale of the hill tribal politics, particularly in Nagaland
and Mizoram. The national parties had avoided serious political infiltration
and involvement in these areas, partly because of the apprehension
that any such step would lead to more resentment and accusations of
cultural domination, and partly because of the caution the national
parties exercised in treading in these violent and insurgent areas.
To a generation of workers in the various national parties in the
Northeast, the likely electoral gains in these areas were too marginal
in comparison with the risks to personal security that were involved. Nobody among the national leaders seemed to
have quite realised, right up to the late 1960s, that the direct involvement
of national political parties in such geographically peripheral areas
would have more than mere electoral implications. No one quite realised
the integrative force of national parties in a democratic set-up.
What motivated Indira Gandhi
to make a serious political infiltration of Mizoram and Nagaland in
the 1970s and 1980s is a matter of conjecture. It is, however, evident
from her speeches and statements in Parliament and elsewhere, that
using electoral politics as a vehicle for ethnic accommodation became
her avowed policy in the Northeast immediately after the successful
secession of Bangladesh from Pakistan. The creation of Bangladesh
was recognised as a clear indication that ethnic disparities could
be aggravated to the point of no return if the electoral game was
not played deftly. Her rejection
of the Pataskar Commission Report also demonstrated that she had taken
the demand for tribal autonomy more seriously than her predecessors
had, and the idea of the so-called balkanisation of the Northeast
had taken roots in her psyche much before the 1971 war with Pakistan.
The work on the North-Eastern (Reorganisation) Act had started in
New Delhi at least two years before its actual enactment in 1971.
The subsequent involvement in the electoral politics of Mizoram and
Nagaland was a veritable political incentive structure in one package.
It was seen by Indira Gandhi as the only way she and her party
could directly influence the course of events in these geo-politically
sensitive States which had been allowed to remain restive for over
two decades. [19]
Her timing was perfect. The
acknowledged military superiority of India in the region in early
1972 was the right moment to play the card of devolution and electoral
politics to counter separatism.
In this respect, therefore,
the merger of the Mizo Union with the Indian National Congress in
1974 had serious implications. First,
it meant that a national party, which had been traditionally, and
largely because of the British indoctrination, regarded as the party
of the dominant Hindus, was now acceptable to the Christian Mizos.
This multi-ethnic political coalition was the greatest achievement
in an area riven by secessionist internal war. The old fears of the
tribal leaders were either found to be untenable, or they had dissolved
under the weight of the new political exigencies imposed by Indias
emergence as a credible and prestigious regional power, and the corresponding
and severe reduction of the power, prestige and delivery capacity
of their erstwhile foreign supporter, Pakistan.
The Congress party also became
the rallying ground for all those who had deserted the Mizo National
Front and had either surrendered in response to the amnesty offer
or had recently come out of prisons after terms of detention or imprisonment.
Thus a national party fragmented the support the MNF had enjoyed so
far, and effectively prevented it from achieving political domination
again. For most people with MNF antecedents, it was worthwhile to
pitch in with a national party which was perceived as large-hearted
enough to accept ex-rebels within its fold and resourceful enough
to give them a new respectability.
It was perhaps the last time
in the impressive history of the Indian National Congress that the
integrative ethos of the party was deliberately activated to buttress
the unity of India.
Brigadier
Sailo
But the road to that more acquiescent
decade was hazardous. In January
1974, Brigadier Thenphunga Sailo, a decorated officer of the Indian
Army with a distinguished service medal (AVSM), retired and came back
to his home in Mizoram. He first started a Human Rights Committee
with the objective of rendering help in legal measures against the
grouping of villages, to uphold civil rights of the oppressed
civilian population, and to educate the public in upholding their
legal rights against the SFs. These
were populist slogans and attracted a large following immediately.
For a while the sway of the ex-MNF people towards the Congress party
was effectively stopped. On April 17, 1974 Brigadier Sailo formed
a political party known as the People's Conference. Two years later
he was detained under the infamous Mintenance of Internal Security
Act of the Emergency era. Seven months after the Chhunga ministry
resigned on May 9, 1977, elections to the Mizoram legislature returned
the Peoples Conference to victory, and Brigadier Sailo became
the Chief Minister in May 1978.
His party won again in the
mid-term elections of 1979 when he became the Chief Minister of Mizoram
for the second time. Superficially, the defeat of the Congress was
blamed on factors that had brought about the rout of the Congress
and Indira Gandhi in the immediate post-Emergency phase. But Mizoram
politics did not yet reflect the national sentiments and mood, and
Sailo apparently rode the crest of popularity because of his anti-SFs
stance, the promise his success held out for a negotiated MNF settlement
with the Government of India, and the return of the prodigals from
their self-imposed exile in the jungles abroad.
[20]
A total of 500 MNF personnel
surrendered in 1972, mostly without arms. There was no regular army
in Mizo Hills between December 1971 and March 1973 due to the Bangladesh
war and internal security was looked after by the para-military forces.
A number of grouped villages were permitted de-group by
Chhungas, and later Sailos, Union Territory Governments.
The dusk-to-dawn curfew, which had been a permanent feature
of Mizo life for the past thirteen years, was lifted, and the movement-by-permit
system was also abolished. These
relaxations allowed free movement of people, including the insurgents.
The hardcore part of the MNF in Arakan and those who had been trickling
back into India from December 1971, now organised a second, and more
virulent, phase of terrorism in Mizoram. Four groups of 80 men infiltrated from Arakan
and carried out many acts of sabotage, including the blowing up of
the Aizawl Power House. Their chief hitman, Lalhleia,
and his bands indulged in large-scale kidnappings, extortion, assassinations,
murders, looting, arson, sniping and ambushes during 1972-74. Their
first victims were those who had deserted Laldenga. Lalnunmawia, the
ex-Vice-President of MNF who had fallen out with Laldenga and had
since come overground and surrendered, was killed in the Aizawl civil
hospital.
During 1973, there were 40
such killings and 19 ambushes against the SFs. It was discovered that
during the confusion prevailing in East Pakistan in 1971, the Mizo
National Army (MNA) had looted some armouries and acquired more arms.
Their effective strength, which had come down to about 500 in 1971,
had again increased to about 1,000 by the end of 1972.
The Chinese
Connection and Disillusionment
In November 1972, the first
MNF gang of 47 went from Arakan Hills in Burma to China under the
leadership of MNF Major Demokhseik Gangte. They carried a compass
but no maps and, taking the bearing from Arakan to China as 10 degrees
North and confirming directions from the local people, reached their
destination after 13 months. They passed through the Kachin area in
Burma where the Kachin Independent Army (KIA) first mistook them for
agents of the Burmese army and dispossessed them of all the weapons
they were carrying. The KIA, however, provided them with clothing,
food, escort and guides upto the Chinese border after they were convinced
of their bona fides. This
was on condition that the MNA would give them 50 per cent of the arms
and ammunition they would receive from China, as the Nagas had done
before them. The MNA entered Yunnan (Tinsum county) on December 28
1973 and stayed in China for three months and ten days.
The Chinese gave them 3 radio
transmitters/receivers, 32 light machine guns, 12 pistols, 4 rocket-launchers
(M 40) and 78 rockets, 28,614 rounds of ammunition, 32,000 US dollars,
62,000 Burmese Kyats, 69 gold chains of over ten ounces of gold each.
In addition, each person received two pairs of olive-green uniforms,
two pairs of boots, one cap, and one mosquito net, as well as a total
of ten inflatable life-boats for crossing rivers, and some books by
Mao-Tse-Tung.
[21]
The Mizos started on their
return journey in April 1974 and crossed the river Chindwin in Burma
in January 1975. The KIA took only some ammunition and a few gold
chains for their assistance. The MNA had left 3 persons behind in
the Kachin area due to sickness. After two of their men were killed
in an ambush laid by the Burmese army, they tarried in Burma for a
while, after which 27 of them surrendered to the Indian army in Imphal
on June 30, 1975. They obviously were not very happy with their first
encounter with the Chinese and were in fact so disillusioned that
they did not make any serious attempts to return to Mizoram. The Chinese
had correctly assessed the total involvement of the Mizos with Christianity,
which rendered the Communist ideology unacceptable and, beyond treating
this as a goodwill visit and offering some gifts with a view to keeping
the contacts alive, did not make any long-term commitments. In fact,
so disillusioned was this group with the Chinese that its leader,
Demkhosheik, suggested peace talks with the Government of India in
a letter sent from his camp in Burma to Chhunga, the then Chief Minister
of Mizoram.
Meanwhile, on April 23 1975,
another group of twenty Mizos led by MNA Colonel Biakvela arrived
in the Kachin area on the way to China.
They had contacted members of the earlier group while passing
through the Burmese areas adjoining Manipur and discussed with them
both the treatment they could expect in China as well as the possibility
of opening up negotiations with the Government of India.
After hearing about Laldengas visit to New Delhi, they
camped for sometime in a place called Hengmat in Burma and later surrendered
to the Indian Army. In an interesting twist to the situation, they
even requested the Indian Army to provide tents for their encampment
in Burma.
The Last
Great Surge of Terror
On January 10, 1974, the MNF
ambushed S. P. Mukerjee, the Lieutenant Governor of Mizoram. Although
the LG survived the bullet injuries, this incident created a sensation
and prompted re-induction of the regular army in Mizoram. Militarily,
the SFs were back to square one. The killings, sabotage and extortion
continued unabated throughout the year, and there were reports that
some insurgents had been provided with shelter in the houses of the
members of the legislative assembly, civil servants, and police officers.
It was not possible for the SFs to search these houses, as it would
have offended those who had at least outwardly aligned themselves
politically with India.
On January 13, 1975, MNA Captain
Lalhleia along with three others carried out the most daring assassinations.
They drove in a jeep into the police headquarters in broad day-light,
shot dead G. S. Ayra, Inspector General of Police, L. B. Sewa, Deputy
Inspector General of Police and Panchapagesan, Superintendent of Police
while they were in a meeting, and escaped. Although Lahleia, his comrades
and a number of other desperados were soon eliminated by the SFs in
the operations that were launched in the wake of the killings, this
incident improved the sagging image of the MNA almost overnight and
tremendously boosted their morale.
While this was certainly not
the high point in the trajectory of insurgency, its timing was most
unsuitable from the government's point of view. The democratic process
had restarted in Mizoram after formation of the Union Territory. The
masses had apparently had enough of trouble and harassment on account
of the unending guerrilla warfare and most people earnestly desired
peace and development. The cry for independence still struck a responsive
chord in some Mizo hearts, but everybody realised that it was an impossible
dream. There was substantial erosion of support for the MNF, and most
people co-operated with them out of fear rather than as an act of
faith. Despite the serious setback, however, the Government of India
decided not to deviate from the policy it had been pursuing so consistently
for some time. It was hoped that, in the absence of substantial foreign
assistance, [22]
this phase of terrorism would
also become counter-productive sooner or later.